Homemade Pumpkin Peanut Butter Recipe – Easy, Healthy & Dog-Approved

If you’re looking for a delicious way to spoil your furry friend—or even a healthier snack for yourself—this Homemade Pumpkin Peanut Butter Recipe checks every box. Made with real ingredients, this treat offers dogs a boost of essential nutrients while delivering tail-wagging flavor. And guess what? You can enjoy it too!

In this blog post, we’ll explore the many benefits of making pumpkin peanut butter at home, walk through the ingredients, show you how to whip it up, and even explain how to safely add pumpkin seeds. Plus, we’ll answer some of the most common questions dog owners have.

Learn more about how to create holistic meals by visiting Vet-Approved Homemade Dog Food, a great starting point for balanced canine nutrition.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

1. Why Make Homemade Pumpkin Peanut Butter?

The Benefits of Homemade Over Store-Bought

Making your own dog treats at home might seem like a chore, but once you realize what goes into some store-bought options, you’ll think twice.

Most commercial peanut butters contain added sugar, salt, preservatives, and sometimes xylitol, which is highly toxic to dogs even in small amounts. Some also include hydrogenated oils that contribute to weight gain and inflammation. On the other hand, homemade pumpkin peanut butter gives you full control over what your dog is consuming.

Plus, making it at home is surprisingly cost-effective. With just a few affordable pantry staples—natural peanut butter and plain pumpkin puree—you can make a large batch for a fraction of what pet-store spreads cost.

Even better? It’s not just for dogs. This pumpkin peanut butter spread is delicious enough for humans too. Slather it on toast, add it to smoothies, or dip apple slices in it for a fall-inspired snack.

Don’t miss our Meaty Dog Treats if you want other protein-packed ideas for pups.

Nutritional Value for Dogs and Humans

Let’s break down the nutritional profile of the main ingredients:

Ingredient	Key Nutrients	Health Benefits
Pumpkin	Fiber, beta-carotene, Vitamin A, Potassium	Supports digestion, boosts vision, strengthens immunity
Natural Peanut Butter	Protein, Healthy Fats, Vitamin B3, Vitamin E	Builds muscle, supports energy, promotes shiny coat

Pumpkin is especially good for dogs who suffer from mild gastrointestinal issues. It’s loaded with soluble fiber, which helps regulate digestion, reduce inflammation in the gut, and firm up loose stools.

Peanut butter, on the other hand, is a great way to introduce healthy fats into your dog’s diet. It’s also a perfect hiding spot for medication just coat the pill and watch it disappear!

Check out Sweet Potato and Oatmeal Dog Cake for another sweet yet nutritious homemade option.

2. Key Ingredients for Homemade Pumpkin Peanut Butter Recipe

Why Pumpkin Is a Superfood for Dogs

There’s a reason pumpkin is the go-to digestive aid for dogs. Not only is it safe, but it’s also packed with:

• Soluble fiber, which helps absorb excess water in the stool
• Vitamin A and beta-carotene, important for eye health and immune strength
• Potassium, which supports hydration and muscle function

Make sure to use plain canned pumpkin or fresh-cooked pumpkin puree never the spiced pie filling! Those often contain added sugars, nutmeg, and other spices that can upset your dog’s stomach or worse.

The Role of Natural Peanut Butter in Your Recipe

While dogs love peanut butter for its smell and flavor, not all peanut butter is created equal. You need one that’s:

• Unsweetened and unsalted
• Free from xylitol
• Made with minimal ingredients (ideally just peanuts)

Peanut butter is a source of monounsaturated fats and vitamin E, both of which support healthy skin and coat. It’s also a great training tool when used in moderation.

Here’s a quick ingredient checklist:

Must-Have Ingredients	Why It Matters
Plain Pumpkin Puree	High in fiber, gut-friendly
Natural Peanut Butter	Protein, healthy fat, energy
Optional: Cinnamon (tiny pinch)	Adds aroma, supports joint health
Optional: Coconut Oil	Boosts shine in coat, aids digestion

3. Step-by-Step Guide to Making Pumpkin Peanut Butter

Required Ingredients and Equipment

You don’t need fancy tools—just a bowl and spoon (or blender if you want an ultra-smooth consistency).

Ingredients:

• 1 cup unsweetened pumpkin puree (not pumpkin pie mix)
• ½ cup natural peanut butter (no added salt, sugar, or xylitol)
• Optional: 1 tbsp melted coconut oil
• Optional: ¼ tsp cinnamon (Ceylon cinnamon preferred)

Equipment:

• Mixing bowl
• Spoon or spatula
• Airtight glass jar or BPA-free container
• Food processor (optional for creamier texture)

Pro Tip: Want to make it even more special? Add 1 tbsp of ground flaxseed for omega-3s or crushed pumpkin seeds for crunch.

Mixing and Storing Instructions

Step 1: Combine Ingredients
In a mixing bowl, add your pumpkin puree and peanut butter. If using coconut oil and cinnamon, toss those in too.

Step 2: Mix Well
Use a spoon or spatula to blend everything together until you get a smooth, even texture. For a creamier result, run it through a food processor for about 1 minute.

Step 3: Store Properly
Transfer the finished product into an airtight jar. Store in the refrigerator for up to 10–14 days. You can also freeze small spoonfuls in silicone molds for longer storage.

Usage Ideas:

• Use as a KONG filler
• Spread on a dog biscuit
• Spoon-feed as a treat
• Serve on a lick mat

4. Variations of Pumpkin Peanut Butter Recipes

Adding Pumpkin Seeds and Other Healthy Mix-ins

Want to take your Homemade Pumpkin Peanut Butter Recipe up a notch? Try experimenting with extra wholesome ingredients. These variations can enhance nutrition while keeping things exciting for your pup.

Popular Add-Ins:

Ingredient	Benefits	Serving Tip
Ground Pumpkin Seeds	Rich in magnesium, iron, zinc, and omega-3	Use 1 tbsp per cup of mixture
Ground Flaxseed	Omega-3 fatty acids for skin & coat health	Start with 1 tsp
Coconut Oil	Promotes digestion and immune strength	Melt before mixing in
Ceylon Cinnamon	Anti-inflammatory, supports joints	Use sparingly (¼ tsp max)
Greek Yogurt	High in protein, gut-friendly probiotics	Mix just before serving

Note: When adding seeds, always grind or crush them for better digestion. Never use salted or flavored pumpkin seeds.

These variations make it easy to tailor the peanut butter recipe to your dog’s specific needs—whether they need help with dry skin, energy, digestion, or picky eating.

Turning the Mixture into Frozen Dog Treats or Biscuits

The basic pumpkin peanut butter blend is already delicious, but transforming it into frozen bites or baked goodies opens up a world of possibilities.

1. Frozen Dog Treats

• Spoon the mixture into silicone molds or ice cube trays
• Freeze for 3–4 hours
• Store in a freezer-safe bag
• Great for hot days or teething puppies

2. Homemade Biscuits

• Add 1½ cups of oat or rice flour to the mixture
• Roll into small balls or cut with dog treat cutters
• Bake at 325°F (163°C) for 20–25 minutes
• Cool completely before storing

Frozen and baked versions are excellent for variety, plus they last longer than the fridge-stored paste.

5. Storage, Shelf-Life, and Safety Tips

How to Properly Store Your Homemade Mix

Since your pumpkin peanut butter is made with fresh, preservative-free ingredients, proper storage is critical to keeping it safe for your dog to enjoy.

Best Practices:

• Refrigerate Immediately after making
• Store in a glass jar or BPA-free airtight container
• Keep the jar tightly sealed to avoid exposure to air or bacteria
• Label the container with the preparation date

If stored correctly, your homemade spread will stay fresh in the fridge for 10–14 days.

Can You Freeze It?

Absolutely! To freeze:

• Spoon into small portions (silicone molds work best)
• Freeze solid, then transfer to a zip-sealed freezer bag
• Store up to 3 months in the freezer

When you’re ready to serve, thaw in the refrigerator overnight.

Signs of Spoilage and When to Discard

Don’t take chances with spoiled food, especially for dogs. Discard your batch immediately if you notice:

• A sour or fermented smell
• Visible mold or discoloration
• Watery separation beyond the normal peanut oil
• Slimy texture

Even with refrigeration, homemade foods have a shorter life span. When in doubt, throw it out.

6. Health Benefits of Pumpkin and Peanut Butter Combo

Digestive Support and Fiber Content

Pumpkin is widely used by vets to support digestive health in dogs. It’s packed with soluble fiber, which:

• Absorbs excess water in the intestines
• Helps relieve both diarrhea and constipation
• Supports beneficial gut bacteria

Just a tablespoon or two added to your dog’s meal can make a noticeable difference.

Peanut butter, although not fiber-rich, pairs well by adding healthy calories and encouraging picky eaters to enjoy their meals.

Together, they form a perfect balance of fiber and fat—ideal for dogs with sensitive stomachs or irregular digestion.

Healthy Fats, Proteins, and Vitamins

Peanut butter brings high-quality plant-based protein and monounsaturated fats, which support:

• Muscle recovery
• Shiny coat
• Sustained energy

Meanwhile, pumpkin delivers vitamins like:

• Vitamin A: essential for eye health
• Vitamin C: boosts immunity
• Potassium: helps with muscle contractions and nerve function

This combo can benefit dogs of all ages—from playful puppies to aging seniors needing joint and digestive support.

If your dog tends to shed a lot or deal with dull fur, adding this peanut butter mixture 2–3 times per week can noticeably improve coat condition.

Nutrient	Found In	Benefit
Soluble Fiber	Pumpkin	Regulates bowel movements
Niacin & Vitamin E	Peanut Butter	Supports skin and coat
Healthy Fats	Both	Aids energy and cognitive health
Antioxidants	Pumpkin	Fights inflammation & boosts immunity

Discover great ideas like Sweet Potato and Oatmeal Dog Cake to include more superfoods in your dog’s diet.

7. Can You Use Pumpkin Seeds in the Recipe?

Are Pumpkin Seeds Safe for Dogs?

Yes plain, unsalted, and unseasoned pumpkin seeds are perfectly safe for dogs when given in moderation and prepared correctly. In fact, they’re packed with important nutrients that support your dog’s overall well-being.

Here’s what makes them a smart addition:

• Zinc – Strengthens immune system
• Magnesium – Supports bone and muscle health
• Omega-3 fatty acids – Reduces inflammation and promotes a healthy coat
• Tryptophan – Can help improve mood and restfulness

However, raw whole seeds can be hard to digest. That’s why you should always roast them (without oil or seasoning) and grind them before adding to the peanut butter mixture.

How to Prepare Pumpkin Seeds for Safe Use

To keep your dog safe and maximize the health benefits:

Step-by-step preparation:

1. Scoop seeds from a fresh pumpkin
2. Rinse to remove stringy pulp
3. Pat dry with a paper towel
4. Spread seeds on a baking tray
5. Bake at 325°F (160°C) for 10–12 minutes
6. Cool completely and grind in a food processor

Add just 1 teaspoon of ground pumpkin seed per cup of pumpkin peanut butter. That’s more than enough for added nutrients without risking stomach upset.

Avoid flavored, salted, or commercial snack pumpkin seeds—they may contain garlic, onion powder, or salt, all of which are harmful to dogs.

8. Common Mistakes to Avoid When Making Dog Treats

Avoiding Additives, Xylitol, and Harmful Ingredients

The biggest mistake pet owners make when crafting homemade recipes like this is assuming all peanut butter or canned pumpkin is safe. Unfortunately, not all pantry items are created equal.

Watch out for these:

• Xylitol – Found in many sugar-free peanut butters and deadly to dogs
• Salt – Too much sodium can lead to dehydration or salt poisoning
• Spices like nutmeg – Found in pumpkin pie mix, toxic to dogs
• Artificial preservatives – Can trigger allergies or digestive issues

Stick to natural ingredients and always read the label—even if the brand says “organic” or “natural.”

Tips to Ensure Your Dog’s Safety and Taste Preference

Even if you use safe ingredients, your dog might still turn their nose up. To keep your pup happy and healthy:

• Introduce the recipe in small amounts
• Mix it into kibble or use as a toy filler
• If freezing, test a thawed bite first for taste preference
• Always consult your vet if your dog has known allergies

You want your Homemade Pumpkin Peanut Butter Recipe to be both safe and enjoyable, so always monitor how your dog reacts the first few times you serve it.

Learn more about nutrient-rich meals in our guide to Vet-Approved Homemade Dog Food.

9. FAQs

Can I mix pumpkin with peanut butter?

Absolutely. In fact, it’s one of the best flavor combos for dogs. Both ingredients are safe, healthy, and full of nutrients. Just be sure to use unsweetened pumpkin puree and natural peanut butter without xylitol or added salt.

Are peanut butter and pumpkin good together?

Yes, especially for dogs. The pumpkin offers digestive fiber and immune-boosting vitamins, while the peanut butter provides protein and healthy fats. It’s also a great combo for hiding medication or training.

How is pumpkin butter made?

Pumpkin butter is typically made by slow-cooking pumpkin puree with spices and sweeteners. However, that version isn’t safe for dogs. For pets, use just pumpkin and peanut butter—no added sugar or spices like nutmeg or clove.

Can we add pumpkin seeds to peanut butter?

Yes, when prepared correctly. Roast them plain, grind them finely, and add a small amount to the mixture. They’re rich in omega-3s and zinc, making your homemade spread even healthier.

Are pumpkin seeds nut safe?

Pumpkin seeds are technically seeds not nuts so they are nut-safe for most dogs with tree nut sensitivities. However, always start with a small amount and monitor for reactions, especially if your pup has known allergies.

Conclusion

There you have it—a complete guide to making your own Homemade Pumpkin Peanut Butter Recipe that’s delicious, nutrient-packed, and dog-safe. Whether you use it as a lick mat topper, treat filler, or training reward, this easy recipe brings joy to dogs and peace of mind to pet parents.

Looking for inspiration? Try Sweet Potato and Oatmeal Dog Cake to expand your treat-making game even further.

For more recipes follow me on PINTEREST

Print